LLB news and views logo

Victory for choice

Lynne Kelly was not the first woman whose partner took her to court attempting to prevent her having an abortion. Leonora Lloyd reports

Although this was the first Scottish case, there have been a number of cases in England and others in Europe, a couple of which were taken to the European courts. In every case the man lost.

Lynne Kelly's ex-partner is a violent man who was convicted of assaulting her last year - something about which he lied in court, but the press exposed him. He openly declared that he had no intention of supporting the resulting child - and, indeed, he has another child, now aged three, whom he does not support.

Neither the church, despite the propaganda it had put out about abortion before the election, nor any anti-abortion organisation appear to have supported him and he dropped the case when he ran out of money. Although a Scottish tabloid paid him for his story, most of the press supported Lynne - reflecting public opinion. She had her abortion, saying afterwards: "I've no regrets."

Meanwhile, the much-hyped offer by Cardinal Thomas Winning to give money to pregnant women not to abort has been quietly forgotten. No woman is known to have come forward - although people did make donations!

Overall recent events have strengthened the pro-choice forces in Scotland and emphasised that public opinion is on their side.

July '97 index of LLB

LLB home page